Close Menu
Eden Prairie Local News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Wednesday, May 21
    • About
      • About EPLN
      • Team
      • EPLN in the News
      • Policies
    • Contact
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Threads LinkedIn
    Subscribe
    Eden Prairie Local News
    • Home
    • Schools
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Public Safety
    • City
    • Calendar
    • Subscribe
    • Donate
    • More
      • Construction
      • Outdoors
      • Politics
      • Health
      • Spirituality
      • Community Service
      • Legacy
      • Obituaries
      • Arts
      • Family
      • Holidays
      • Letter to Editor
      • Listen
      • Jobs
    Eden Prairie Local News
    Home»City of Eden Prairie»Court rules for city in land-use appeal
    City of Eden Prairie

    Court rules for city in land-use appeal

    Mark WeberBy Mark WeberMarch 20, 20242 Mins Read
    The Minnesota Court of Appeals has supported the Eden Prairie City Council’s 2021 rejection of a plan to build a service station/convenience store and auto-repair business on this parcel at the intersection of County Road 1 (Pioneer Trail) and Hennepin Town Road in southeastern Eden Prairie. Photo by Mark Weber

    The Minnesota Court of Appeals has affirmed a lower court’s ruling that the City of Eden Prairie did not act improperly when it rejected a plan for a service station/convenience store and auto-repair business in September 2021.

    A three-judge panel made the ruling on March 18.

    The court case focused on a proposal by EP Land, LLC and Auto Care World, LLC to build a 24-hour Holiday service station/convenience store/car wash and 10-bay Auto Care World auto-repair business on a four-acre, “L”-shaped lot near the intersection of County Road 1 (Pioneer Trail) and Hennepin Town Road in southeastern Eden Prairie.

    Agreeing with neighbors opposed to the plan, the Eden Prairie City Council unanimously concluded that the project was oversized, given its close proximity to adjacent homes and reliance on neighborhood streets to handle traffic. It also said the plan did not warrant the requested waivers from city code. After voting against the plan, the city amended its zoning ordinance to remove gas stations from the zoning district called “neighborhood commercial.”

    Advertisement
    Ad for Washburn McReavy

    The developer filed a district-court lawsuit against the city a few months later.

    On April 4, 2023, district court Judge Thomas J. Conley granted summary judgment in favor of the city, saying the council’s 2021 denial of the project was reasonable and did not constitute a “regulatory taking” because alternative development options remain. 

    Ten days later, the plaintiffs filed an appeal.

    In their March 18 ruling, the Court of Appeal judges ruled in support of the lower court, stating that the city had “rational legal and factual bases” for denying the development application and that local officials’ denial of the project did not constitute a regulatory taking.

    Bryan Huntington, the attorney for EP Land and Auto Care World, did not comment on the ruling.

    On behalf of the city, attorneys Katherine Swenson and John Baker provided a statement saying, “The City of Eden Prairie is pleased with the Minnesota Court of Appeals’ unanimous decision affirming the district court’s ruling in the City’s favor, and with its reasoning. The decision reflects that the Court of Appeals, like the district court, reviewed the evidence and the law carefully.”

    The property in question remains vacant.

    Comments
    We offer several ways for our readers to provide feedback. Your comments are welcome on our social media posts (Facebook, X, Instagram, Threads, and LinkedIn). We also encourage Letters to the Editor; submission guidelines can be found on our Contact Us page. If you believe this story has an error or you would like to get in touch with the author, please connect with us.

    Be Informed
    Sign up for the FREE email newsletter from EPLN
    Subscribe
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleRobert Gene Twiss
    Next Article EP plans Prairie Center Drive upgrades

    More to READ

    10 Mins Read

    Getting where you need to go – with less driving

    May 8, 2025
    6 Mins Read

    Eden Prairie Schools’ centennial bash wins heritage honor

    May 8, 2025
    6 Mins Read

    Where does the recycling go?

    April 30, 2025
    Subscribe to get EPLN in your inbox for FREE!
    Recent Articles

    Eden Prairie High School program gives seniors a head start on careers

    May 21, 2025

    Shakopee man charged in Eden Prairie sexual assault of 15-year-old girl

    May 21, 2025

    EPHS synchronized swim team advances to state meet

    May 20, 2025

    Minnesota legislative session ends, still with a long to-do list

    May 20, 2025

    Former Eden Prairie man sentenced for posting nude images of woman online without her consent

    May 20, 2025
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    INN Network Member Guidestar Seal
    Eden Prairie Local News is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization EIN 85-4248265 | Copyright © 2020-2025
    • About
    • Policies
    • Jobs
    • Contact
    • Advertising
    • Subscribe
    • Donate

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.